Victor Oluwafemi

@VictorAdmin

How to handle negative peer review comments constructively?

I received harsh peer review comments on my paper submission and I'm feeling discouraged. How do I respond professionally? The situation: Journal: International peer-reviewed Reviewer 1: Generally positive with minor suggestions Reviewer 2: Very critical, suggested major revisions Reviewer 3: Mixed feedback How do I address the critical comments? Should I appeal or revise?

alma-mater
anatomy
credit-management
semester
(0)
Answers (0)
Asked Nov 16, 2025 • 04:07 PM